Immigration Office Unjustly Bans Online Degree Programs
Can the Immigration Office Require In-Person Study Only? A Kenyan student wants to extend his residence permit for study purposes. The Immigration Office takes the position that the residence permit can only be maintained if the studies are completed in person. The applicant did not agree with this and filed a lawsuit seeking an extension of his residence permit. This raises the question: Can the Immigration Office make in-person study a requirement, even though § 16b of the Residence Act does not expressly state this?
In its decision of March 20, 2026 – VG 24 L 1/26, the Berlin Administrative Court ruled that a residence permit for study purposes under § 16b of the Residence Act may not be made contingent on the requirement that the program be exclusively in-person. In practice, this means: The Foreigners’ Office may not automatically require that a degree program be recognized for residence purposes only if it mandates compulsory attendance in the lecture hall, subject to penalties. At least in cases where the student actually attends the in-person classes offered as part of a full-time program, they satisfy the requirement to reside in the Federal Republic of Germany specifically for the purpose of full-time study. The decisive factor is that the studies constitute the primary reason for the stay and that the student actually attends in-person classes. Other activities of the foreign national within the federal territory are irrelevant as long as the primary purpose remains the course of study and the student is studying in good standing. The Chamber bases its decision on the wording of the law, the legislative rationale, and the EU legal requirements of the REST Directive, which do not require a stricter interpretation.
The court thus clarifies: What matters is whether the legal requirements for a residence permit for study purposes are met. Whether a degree program is organized entirely or partially online is not sufficient grounds to deny or revoke a residence permit. What is decisive is not the label “in-person study,” but the legal basis.
For students from third countries, the decision is an important argument against a blanket official requirement for in-person courses. Those pursuing a distance or hybrid program can rely on the fact that the right of residence is not automatically tied to an attendance requirement.
Cultural Remark
We know that in some cultures people prefer to avoid court cases and open conflict and seek an amicable agreement instead. With German authorities, this does not work. Once the authority has rejected your application, there is nothing left to discuss or negotiate. The case is closed, “GAME OVER”. And if it does not decide at all, polite enquiries usually do not help either.
Are you worried about disadvantages if you defend yourself? Don’t be, in Germany people take this in their stride. The authority may not treat your application less favourably just because you “dared” to file an objection or take legal action. Having your case reviewed by a higher authority or a court is your right. It has nothing to do with rebellion or lèse-majesté. If the authority loses, it continues processing your application as if nothing had happened. At most, your case gets a new caseworker.
And if you lose, at least you know exactly why your application failed and what you can do better next time.